Successful TC Federal Acquisition and Integration Progress
Legal close completed at beginning of December; systems conversion on track for Q1 2026. Management reports deal financial targets are on track or better than expected and projected cost savings and deal economics improved versus original modeling (earn-back now expected to be <2.5 years).
Improved Operating Performance and Profitability
Operating net income increased by $675,000 quarter-over-quarter. Achieved a 1.0% operating ROA for fiscal year 2025 (management target) and set a new target of 1.20% ROA with expectation to achieve quarterly beginning Q2 2026 and full-year 2026.
Net Interest Income and Margin Expansion
Net interest income rose approximately $3.2 million versus the prior quarter. Net interest margin increased 15 basis points to 3.32% in the quarter, driven by higher earning asset yields and lower cost of funds.
Strong Loan Yield and Core Loan Growth
Loan yields increased to 6.19% from 6.15% quarter-over-quarter. Core organic loan growth for 2025 was 10.5% (excluding the TC Federal acquisition). Management expects modest margin expansion through 2026 driven by loan repricing.
Robust Complementary Lines of Business and Noninterest Income
Operating noninterest income was $11.1 million in Q4 with notable strength in mortgage and SBSL. Executed a $10 million portfolio mortgage pool sale with a gain of about $108,000. Management expects noninterest income to be slightly better in 2026.
Asset Management and Insurance Growth
Assets under management more than doubled from ~ $200 million at end of 2024 to over $460 million at end of 2025. Bank referrals to insurance increased 20% in 2025 and Colony Insurance showed year-over-year improvement in items and premiums in force.
Capital, Book Value and Shareholder Returns
Tangible common equity (TCE) ratio improved to 8.30% (from 8.00% prior quarter). Tangible book value per share increased to $14.31 from $14.24. Board increased quarterly dividend to $0.12 per share (up $0.02 annualized) and repurchased 47,000 shares at an average price of $16.50.
Balance Sheet and AOCI Improvements
Fair value of the investment portfolio improved quarter-over-quarter, producing a positive impact to accumulated other comprehensive income (AOCI) of about $2.5 million. Management highlighted opportunity to re-deploy payoffs at current market rates to support earnings.
Recognition and Talent Additions
Colony named one of American Bankers 2025 Best Banks to Work For (only Georgia-headquartered bank on the list). Added two financial advisers and transitioned to a dual-employee broker-dealer model; expects long-term revenue upside from AUM and adviser model conversion.