It took just one report to send BP stock (BP) climbing. And just one sentence from Shell (SHEL) to send the rumor mill spinning even faster.
Confident Investing Starts Here:
- Easily unpack a company's performance with TipRanks' new KPI Data for smart investment decisions
- Receive undervalued, market resilient stocks right to your inbox with TipRanks' Smart Value Newsletter
On Thursday, Shell formally denied any intention to acquire its British rival BP, stating flatly that it “has no intention of making a takeover offer.” The statement followed a Wall Street Journal report claiming that early talks were underway for what would be “the largest oil deal in a generation.”
And just like that, the market had whiplash.
But in M&A, especially in Big Oil, a denial doesn’t always mean no. It often means not now.
Why This Statement Matters More Than It Seems
In the UK, takeover rules are strict. By issuing the denial, Shell has now triggered a regulatory freeze: under U.K. law, the company is “largely” barred from making a formal offer for BP for six months—unless another bidder appears or BP itself invites Shell back to the table.
Which means Shell’s move may not be a retreat—it may be a reset. The kind that gives Shell strategic distance while BP digests the headlines, absorbs investor pressure, and potentially softens its stance behind closed doors.
Scale Isn’t Just Strategy, It’s Survival
Why would Shell want BP in the first place?
Because scale, in an era of accelerating energy transition, is no longer just about efficiency. It’s about endurance. BP, despite its messy balance sheet and complex asset base, brings unmatched integration—upstream, downstream, trading, and one of the most respected energy brand names in the world.
But it also brings baggage. Net debt of $27 billion, with an additional $38 billion in disclosed liabilities. Regulatory scrutiny. ESG backlash. A tangled corporate structure. Buying BP isn’t plug-and-play, it’s open-heart surgery.
Still, with oil majors racing to secure long-term footing in low-carbon infrastructure and global LNG markets, BP’s existing platform could be both a launchpad and a shield.
BP’s Clock Is Ticking
For now, Shell’s denial gives BP CEO Murray Auchincloss a window to get his house in order. But that window might close quickly.
BP’s future—whether as a solo act, a strategic partner, or a takeover target—remains uncertain. And that uncertainty is now priced into every conversation, boardroom strategy, and shareholder vote.
Shell may be sidelined for six months. But the clock is ticking—and so is the pressure on BP to prove it can still stand on its own.
Is Shell a Good Stock to Buy Now?
Even as Shell plays defense on the BP takeover narrative, investor sentiment around the stock remains decidedly bullish. Based on 13 Wall Street analysts who rated the stock in the past three months, Shell currently holds a “Strong Buy” consensus, with 11 Buy ratings and zero Sells.
The average 12-month price target sits at €35.86 — implying an 18.18% upside from the current level of €30.35. It seems that even without a megadeal in play, Shell still has headroom to run.
