PayPal stock (PYPL) has struggled to find a floor. Shares have dropped about 14% since the company reported third-quarter results on Oct. 28 and are now down roughly 26% for the year. Over the same stretch, the S&P 500 (SPX) has gained more than 14%, underlining how far the once-favored fintech has fallen out of step with the broader market.
TipRanks Black Friday Sale
- Claim 60% off TipRanks Premium for the data-backed insights and research tools you need to invest with confidence.
- Subscribe to TipRanks' Smart Investor Picks and see our data in action through our high-performing model portfolio - now also 60% off
Investors are now parsing a string of insider transactions that arrived just as the post-earnings drift gathered pace. This has raised new queries about confidence inside the C-suite.
Insider Sales Add to Post-Earnings Pressure
Regulatory filings show several PayPal leaders trimming positions in recent weeks. Chief accounting officer Chris Natali sold 1,374 shares on Oct. 30 at an average price of $69.13, bringing in nearly $95,000. The filing said Natali held no PayPal shares directly after the sale.
A few days later, Suzan Kereere, president of global markets, sold 10,000 shares at an average of $68.85 and another 2,500 shares at $68.96 on Nov. 3. These trades totaled about $860,900 and left her with 30,983 shares, worth roughly $1.9 million at Friday’s close of $62.81.
There was more activity the following week. Global chief risk officer Aaron Webster disclosed three sales on Nov. 10 totaling 9,282 shares for proceeds of about $615,309. He still directly owns 35,699 shares, valued at more than $2.2 million at the same closing price.
PayPal has not commented on the individual transactions. Insider sales do not automatically signal trouble, since they can reflect tax planning or portfolio diversification. The timing so soon after earnings, however, adds another data point for investors already watching the stock’s slide.
Alex Chriss Pushes Turnaround While Shares Lag
Since taking over as CEO in 2023, Alex Chriss has tried to reset expectations around PayPal’s business model. His strategy centers on slimming down lower-margin, unbranded operations and focusing on higher-return core services where the PayPal name still carries weight with merchants and consumers.
Recent earnings reports have been solid on paper, yet the stock reaction has stayed negative. Investors want to see faster improvement in key measures such as online branded checkout growth and evidence that PayPal can defend pricing against rivals.
The gap between market hopes and current performance remains wide. PayPal once commanded a premium multiple when shares hit a record closing high of $308.53 in July 2021. At around $63 today, the company is still fighting to convince the market that its next phase of growth can justify anything close to those old valuations.
Investors can track which insiders buy or sell stocks in real-time on the TipRanks Insider Trading Tool. Click on the image below to find out more.
