Palantir Technologies Inc. (PLTR) has found itself in a legal battle that is catching the attention of both Silicon Valley and Wall Street. On Wednesday, three former employees filed court documents in Manhattan, arguing that the data giant is using a “scare tactic” lawsuit to crush their new startup, Percepta. While the legal drama unfolds, Palantir stock has remained relatively steady, closing Tuesday at $178.96.
Claim 70% Off TipRanks Premium
- Unlock hedge fund-level data and powerful investing tools for smarter, sharper decisions
- Stay ahead of the market with the latest news and analysis and maximize your portfolio's potential
What Is the Dispute Really About?
The dispute centers on Percepta, an AI consultancy founded by former Palantir engineers Radha Jain, Joanna Cohen, and Hirsh Jain. Palantir claims the trio stole “crown jewels,” including proprietary source code, to build a copycat competitor. However, the former employees hit back in their latest filing, claiming Palantir’s non-compete agreements are so broad they are “unenforceable” and designed primarily to stop talent from leaving.
Why the Legal Row Matters for Palantir Stock
From an economic perspective, Palantir’s aggressive stance is a defensive move to protect its “moat.” The company has invested billions of dollars into its ontology and AI platforms, and allowing top engineers to leave and start “mini-Palantirs” could dilute its market dominance. If Palantir wins, it sends a strong message that its intellectual property is a fortress. However, if the court agrees with the ex-employees that the non-competes are “overbroad,” it could make it easier for other staff to leave, potentially leading to a brain drain” that could worry long-term investors in Palantir stock.
It’s a Battle over Non-Competes
The core of the “scare tactic” argument is about how much control a company should have over its former workers. The ex-employees argue that Palantir’s contracts would effectively ban them from working at any firm that uses AI to help customers—a definition that covers almost the entire tech industry today. This case is being watched closely because the U.S. government recently shifted its stance on these rules. While a nationwide ban on non-competes was recently set aside, federal agencies are still encouraging courts to throw out “unreasonable” contracts that stop people from moving between jobs.
Palantir Stock Is Still a Very Strong Performer
Despite the courtroom drama, Palantir stock has been one of the strongest performers over the last year, up over 170% as it secures massive government and commercial AI contracts. Most analysts see this lawsuit as “business as usual” for a company founded by Peter Thiel, who is known for his aggressive business strategies. While the lawsuit might be a distraction, the real lifeline for the stock remains its ability to convert its high-tech software into growing profits.
Is Palantir a Good Stock to Buy Now?
TipRanks data shows Palantir Technologies (PLTR) carries a “Hold” consensus rating from 17 Wall Street analysts over the past three months. The breakdown includes five Buys, 10 Holds, and two Sells.
The average 12-month PLTR price target stands at $192.88, implying a modest 7.8% upside from the latest close.
