Coca-Cola’s (KO) long-running ambition to build a global retail coffee powerhouse is losing steam. Reports that the company is exploring a potential sale of Costa Coffee mark a sharp turn from the bold confidence that surrounded the 2018 acquisition. Back then, Costa was positioned as Coke’s gateway into hot beverages and in-store retail dominance. Today, it is increasingly viewed inside the market as a business that never quite fit the parent company’s operating model.
TipRanks Black Friday Sale
- Claim 60% off TipRanks Premium for the data-backed insights and research tools you need to invest with confidence.
- Subscribe to TipRanks' Smart Investor Picks and see our data in action through our high-performing model portfolio - now also 60% off
The valuation gap tells the story. Coca-Cola paid nearly $5 billion for Costa at the peak of the coffee expansion boom. Any sale now would likely come at a steep discount. The reality does not threaten Coca-Cola’s balance sheet, but it does send a signal that retail coffee has become far harder to scale profitably than originally expected.
High-Street Costs Squeeze Costa’s Core Business
Costa’s problems are not rooted in demand alone. The chain still generates substantial revenue, but profitability has remained elusive as energy costs, wages, rent, and raw materials continue to rise. High-street foot traffic has also failed to fully recover its pre-pandemic rhythm, leaving many locations underutilized while fixed costs stay stubbornly high.
Competition has intensified at the same time. Premium independents, convenience-led formats, and rivals like Pret have captured younger customers who care as much about experience as price. Costa now sits in an uncomfortable middle ground, too mass-market for the craft crowd and too costly to compete in pure discount terms.
A Costa Exit Would Signal a Retreat for Coca-Cola
If Coca-Cola ultimately exits Costa Coffee, it would mark a rare public retreat from one of its most ambitious diversification efforts. The company built its empire on scalable beverages and distribution efficiency. Retail cafés demand different skills entirely. Labor management, real estate exposure, and local pricing dynamics leave far less room for error.
For investors, the bigger issue is not the write-down itself. It is what the reversal says about Coca-Cola’s future growth strategy. A retreat from Costa would suggest a renewed focus on higher-margin concentrate models over physical storefront expansion.
At the high-street level, a change in ownership could reset Costa’s strategy yet again. Store closures, rebranding, or tighter franchising could follow. For Coca-Cola, however, the Costa chapter increasingly looks like a lesson in how even the strongest global brands can struggle when the business model shifts from bottles to baristas.
Is Coca Cola a Good Stock to Buy?
Analyst sentiment toward Coca-Cola remains firmly positive despite near-term questions around Costa Coffee and high-street competition. Wall Street currently rates the stock a Strong Buy, with 14 of 15 analysts calling it a Buy, one says a Hold, and none recommending a Sell. The average 12-month KO price target sits at $79.08, implying roughly 8.5% upside from current levels.
