Microsoft’s (MSFT) aggressive push to lead the AI revolution hits a wall of user frustration and branding confusion. While CEO Satya Nadella stakes the company’s future on becoming an AI-first firm, recent data indicates that the Copilot chatbot is losing its grip on the market it helped create. Despite being woven into the fabric of Windows and Microsoft 365, the product is increasingly being sidelined by users who find more value in rival tools.
Claim 50% Off TipRanks Premium
- Unlock hedge fund-level data and powerful investing tools for smarter, sharper decisions
- Stay ahead of the market with the latest news and analysis and maximize your portfolio's potential
Analysts Signal a Preference Shift
A massive survey of over 150,000 U.S. respondents by Recon Analytics reveals a troubling trend for the tech giant. Between July 2025 and late January 2026, the percentage of subscribers who use Copilot as their primary AI option tumbled from 18.8% to just 11.5%. During that same window, Google Gemini saw its share of users climb from 12.8% to 15.7%, while OpenAI‘s ChatGPT continues to dominate the landscape.
Nadella Distinguishes ‘Spectacle’ from ‘Substance’
The struggle comes at a pivotal moment. In a December blog post, Nadella acknowledged the shifting landscape, writing that “we have moved past the initial phase of discovery” and that the industry is now entering a phase where “we are beginning to distinguish between ‘spectacle’ and ‘substance.’”
However, technical and organizational hurdles currently obscure that substance for many enterprise users. Branding chaos leaves customers baffled by the lack of a cohesive experience across different versions like M365, Pro, Sales, and Windows. This friction intensifies when interoperability fails, often leaving the browser-based tool unable to interact with the specific webpage a user is viewing.
Furthermore, Anthropic’s new Claude Cowork creates a growing threat, drawing praise for working across 365 applications more smoothly than Microsoft’s own native offering.
Investors Question the Utilization Gap
While Microsoft recently touted 15 million corporate seats sold for its 365 Copilot, analysts at Citi Research (C) point out a stark reality: some companies are only actively using about 10% of the seats they are paying for. Disorganized data silos within corporate systems often prevent the AI from accessing the information it needs to be useful, leading many workers to revert to Gemini or ChatGPT for their daily tasks.
Key Takeaway
To sum up, Microsoft has the ultimate home field advantage because their software is on almost every office computer in the world. However, being everywhere isn’t the same as being helpful. If users feel like Copilot is being “forced” onto them while performing worse than a free tab of ChatGPT, they will eventually stop clicking the button. Microsoft has the money to win this marathon, but they need to simplify the experience before their captive audience escapes to more intuitive rivals.
Is Microsoft a Good Stock to Buy?
According to TipRanks, Microsoft stock (MSFT) has a consensus Strong Buy rating among 35 Wall Street analysts. This rating is based on 34 Buys and one Hold rating assigned in the past three months. The average 12-month MSFT price target of $603.47 implies 45.3% upside from current levels.
