American Airlines (AAL) stock has gained 38% over the past three months, driven by cautious optimism as analysts anticipate its Q2 earnings, scheduled for release on Thursday. Following a tough Q1, marked by a $473 million net loss, as the company was hit hard by fragile domestic demand and rising costs, Wall Street now anticipates Q2 adjusted EPS of $0.64 to $0.95.
Elevate Your Investing Strategy:
- Take advantage of TipRanks Premium at 50% off! Unlock powerful investing tools, advanced data, and expert analyst insights to help you invest with confidence.
In the meantime, with a towering $36.6 billion debt load, AAL’s investment case remains a high-wire act, blending potential upside with nerve-wracking risks. As a result, every quarterly report, including its upcoming Q2 results, becomes a make-or-break moment. Thus, I remain Neutral on the U.S. airline in advance of its announcement later this week.
Recent Headwinds and Tailwinds for American Airlines
The airline industry is facing strong headwinds this year, with domestic demand softening due to economic uncertainty and tighter consumer spending. American Airlines’ Q1 results reflected these pressures, posting a $473 million net loss ($0.72 per share) and a slight 0.2% year-over-year decline in revenue to $12.6 billion, despite a 0.7% rise in unit revenue.
CEO Robert Isom pointed to strength in international markets, where unit revenue rose 2.9% and managed business revenue—particularly from financial and professional services—climbed 8%. However, a pivot toward regional jet operations and higher labor costs weighed on margins.
American’s AAdvantage loyalty program remains a bright spot, with enrollments up 6% and co-branded credit card spending up 8% YoY in Q1. American’s operational reliability, ranking high among U.S. carriers, and its young fleet, including new Boeing 787-9s with flagship suite seats, bolster its competitive edge. Still, economic headwinds and a now-withdrawn full-year outlook signal caution, as management adjusts to a bifurcated demand environment where international travel outpaces domestic.
What the Market Expects to Happen This Thursday
Two days ahead of its Q2 earnings release, analysts expect American Airlines (AAL) to report adjusted EPS between $0.64 and $0.95—a roughly 30% decline from Q2 2024’s $1.09, with the midpoint at $0.77. Revenue is projected to come in mostly flat year-over-year, ranging from a 2% decline to a 1% increase, potentially reaching $14.3 billion at the high end. This tempered outlook is consistent with Q1 guidance, which cited ongoing softness in domestic main cabin demand and a projected 2–4% capacity increase that could pressure yields.
Higher fuel prices and a greater reliance on costlier regional jet operations are also expected to squeeze margins. A key metric used by analysts and periodically reported by AAL is its “cost per available seat mile,” which measures the strength of AAL’s cost management and operational efficiency. As TipRanks data shows, this metric remains stable despite ticking up to $0.18 last quarter.
Moreover, broader industry headwinds are weighing on expectations. JPMorgan’s (JPM) Jamie Baker and others have revised their forecasts for U.S. airlines downward, citing weakened business travel, softer transborder traffic, and uncertainty surrounding potential tariffs from the Trump administration.
Following Q1, 13 analysts lowered their Q2 earnings estimates for American Airlines. Still, there’s cautious optimism that profitability for the whole year remains within reach, supported by robust international demand—especially in the Pacific region, where passenger revenue is projected to grow 5.8%—and continued momentum in the AAdvantage loyalty program.
Looking ahead, initiatives such as the Citi partnership and the rollout of free Wi-Fi for AAdvantage members in 2026 aim to boost customer retention, although their financial impact won’t be felt this quarter. For now, American Airlines continues to walk a fine line—leveraging its global network and loyalty strengths while managing rising costs and an increasingly competitive domestic landscape.
Valuation and Debt: A High-Stakes Balancing Act
At today’s share price of approximately $12.51 and a market cap of $8.25 billion, American Airlines may look undervalued ahead of its earnings call, trading at a forward P/E of around 6 based on Wall Street’s 2026 EPS forecast of $1.99—a sharp rise from the projected $0.79 in 2025.
This bullish outlook hinges on expected annual revenue growth of 4.3% through 2027 and anticipated cost efficiencies. However, AAL’s sizable debt load of $36.6 billion—vastly outweighing its roughly $4.3 billion in annual operating cash flow—continues to elevate risk, helping explain the stock’s discounted valuation.
The company has made progress, cutting debt by $1.2 billion in Q1 and over $15 billion since 2021, with a target to bring total debt below $35 billion by 2027. Investors will be watching Q2 closely for continued improvement, especially given the $1.7 billion in free cash flow generated last quarter. Still, with AAL operating on a narrow margin for error, any disappointment in Q2 could rattle investor confidence, making this report critical to its near-term upward trajectory.
Is American Airlines a Buy, Sell, or Hold?
Currently, analysts are leaning bullish on AAL stock. The stock carries a Moderate Buy consensus rating, based on seven Buy and five Hold ratings assigned over the past three months. Today, AAL’s average stock price target of $13.91 implies almost 13% upside potential over the next twelve months.
Fragile AAL Market Momentum Ahead of Q2 Earnings Call
American Airlines enters its Q2 earnings with cautious optimism—but with limited margin for error. Strength in its loyalty program and international demand provides some tailwinds, but stagnant revenue growth, rising costs, and a substantial debt burden continue to weigh heavily.
With analysts projecting only modest profitability for the year, Q2 could either reinforce the bullish narrative or heighten investor concerns. In my view, AAL remains a case of fragile momentum, suggesting it may be wiser to wait for a pullback before considering a long position in the stock.