ETSY Stock Stages 35% Resurgence With Higher Highs Expected

Etsy’s (ETSY) stock has been on a wild ride—skyrocketing during the pandemic before plunging in the years that followed as growth stalled. In that time, sales plateaued, buyer numbers fell, and the business struggled to rediscover its momentum. But beneath the surface, Etsy has quietly transformed into a cash flow machine, generating $685 million in free cash flow over the past 12 months. Combine that with aggressive share buybacks and a hefty 22% short interest—a potential powder keg—and its 35% rally from April lows could be just the beginning of a much larger move.

Where Etsy Struggles to Shine

At first glance, Etsy’s investment case doesn’t look particularly compelling. Its latest earnings report paints the picture of a company spinning its wheels. Consolidated gross merchandise sales (GMS) dropped 6.5% year-over-year to $2.8 billion, with the core Etsy Marketplace faring even worse, down 8.9%. On the earnings call, CEO Josh Silverman attributed the weakness to a “challenging environment,” where cost-conscious consumers are prioritizing essentials over Etsy’s unique assortment of handcrafted goods. A newly introduced $29 seller fee, aimed at weeding out lower-quality shops, also led to a trimmed seller base, hardly a catalyst for growth.

Meanwhile, shopper engagement is waning. GMS per buyer declined 3.5% to $120, suggesting users aren’t sticking around or spending like they used to. It’s not that Etsy has lost its appeal—its mobile app now accounts for a record 44.5% of Marketplace GMS—but macroeconomic pressures like inflation and global uncertainty are putting a damper on discretionary spending. Etsy is pushing back with AI-powered personalization to enhance the browsing experience, but for now, that effort feels more like a flicker than a flame.

Other e-commerce players such as Wayfair (W) and eBay (EBAY) are navigating similar headwinds, but Etsy’s niche focus raises the stakes. Without a breakout product category or a surge in new buyers, Etsy remains on the defensive, leaning heavily on its loyal community of artisans and vintage sellers to carry it through. The big question is whether that’s enough to shift the momentum.

Growth That’s Hard to Find

Etsy isn’t just grappling with a tough macro environment—it’s also struggling to keep its core metrics from sliding further. The company is leaning heavily into technology, introducing a new “Discovery Centric Shopping” experience that has nearly doubled engagement on personalized homepages. While promising, these initiatives are still in their infancy, and whether they’ll meaningfully move the needle remains uncertain.

The recent $105 million sale of Reverb, Etsy’s musical instrument marketplace, served as another wake-up call. Though the move helped streamline operations, it came with a steep price: a $102 million non-cash impairment charge that contributed to a painful Q1 EPS miss of -$0.49—well below the $0.47 analysts had expected. The retreat from diversification likely didn’t sit well with investors either. Etsy is now fully committed to its core marketplace, but unloading assets like Reverb can feel more like retrenchment than progress.

Meanwhile, competitive pressure continues to mount. Goliaths like Amazon (AMZN) and Walmart (WMT), with their vast product ranges and competitive pricing, are encroaching on Etsy’s artisanal niche. Etsy’s take rate, which climbed to 23.3% in Q1, is healthy on paper—but without a rebound in buyer demand, it’s more of a cosmetic win. The company is betting on AI and machine learning to deepen shopper engagement, but with consumers tightening their belts, Etsy’s growth engine is sputtering.

A Cash Flow Powerhouse in Disguise

But here’s the plot twist. Despite the growth slump, Etsy has turned into a free cash flow machine. Over the trailing 12 months, the company generated $685 million in FCF, converting an eye-popping 87% of its adjusted EBITDA. In Q1 2025, it pulled in $35 million despite seasonal cash outflows. This wasn’t achieved by chance. Etsy’s capital-light model, connecting buyers and sellers without the burden of inventory, keeps the cash flowing.

CFO Lanny Baker, on the earnings call, called it a “strong financial foundation,” with Etst also having nearly $1 billion in cash on hand. At this stage, management is not pursuing moonshot acquisitions or risky expansions. Instead, it has honed its mature business to run lean and mean, while returning all of its free cash flow back to shareholders in the form of share buybacks.

Buybacks and Shorts: Fuel for a Squeeze?

In particular, with growth on hold, Etsy is doubling down on returning cash to shareholders. Over the past 12 months, it has plowed $820 million into stock buybacks, which, for context, accounts for over 13% of today’s market cap, even after the 35% rally over the past month. In Q1 alone, $189 million was spent on buying back shares, a clear signal that management believes the stock is undervalued at current prices.

Now factor in the 22% short interest, and you’ve got the makings of a high-stakes setup. The recent surge in Etsy’s share price has put pressure on bearish positions, and if the company continues generating strong cash flow while aggressively reducing its share count, those short bets could unwind quickly, setting the stage for a potential short squeeze. With momentum already building, this rally might just be getting started.

Is ETSY Stock a Buy, Sell, or Hold?

Wall Street remains relatively skeptical about Etsy’s prospects. ETSY stock features a Hold consensus rating, with eight analysts currently bullish, 13 neutral, and four bearish. ETSY’s average stock price target of $48.17 indicates ~22% downside potential over the coming twelve months.

See more ETSY analyst ratings

A Stock With Fire in Its Belly

Etsy presents a bit of a paradox. It’s a company facing sluggish growth, yet it’s churning out solid cash flow and buying back shares at an aggressive pace. That 35% rally over the past month isn’t just market noise—it’s underpinned by strong free cash flow and buybacks that signal real confidence in the stock’s intrinsic value.

With 22% of the float sold short, the conditions for a short squeeze are hard to ignore. Growth may be elusive for now, but Etsy’s financial strength and strategic capital returns could continue to drive the stock higher, making it a name worth watching closely.